What Is the Narrative Structure of a Short Story

What defines the narrative structure of a short story?

The narrative structure of a short story is the framework that organizes the plot, characters, and themes into a cohesive and engaging tale. It’s the skeleton upon which the flesh of the story hangs, providing shape and direction to the narrative.

Short stories, by their very nature, demand a tight, focused structure. Every word must count, every scene must serve a purpose, and every character must contribute to the overall narrative. The structure of a short story is typically more condensed and streamlined compared to longer forms of fiction.

Key elements that define short story structure include:

Concision: Short stories must convey a complete narrative arc in a limited word count, usually between 1,000 to 7,500 words. This constraint necessitates a lean, efficient structure.

Single focus: Unlike novels, which can explore multiple plotlines and themes, short stories generally concentrate on a single central conflict or idea.

Limited timeframe: Short stories often take place over a brief period, sometimes even a single day or moment, which impacts their structural organization.

Immediate engagement: With limited space to hook readers, short stories typically begin in medias res (in the middle of things), plunging directly into the action or conflict.

Rapid pacing: The condensed format requires quicker plot development and character arcs, with fewer scenes and transitions than longer works.

Concentrated character development: Characters in short stories are often revealed through actions and dialogue rather than extensive backstory or internal monologues.

Powerful endings: Short stories frequently aim for impactful conclusions that resonate beyond the final sentence, often employing twist endings or epiphanies.

The narrative structure of a short story is not just about organizing events chronologically. It’s about creating a rhythm, building tension, and guiding the reader through an emotional journey. Effective short story structure balances exposition, rising action, climax, and resolution within a compact framework, ensuring each element serves the story’s central purpose.

Understanding and mastering short story structure allows writers to craft compelling narratives that leave lasting impressions on readers, despite their brevity. It’s a skill that requires practice, analysis, and a deep appreciation for the art of concise storytelling.

How do short story structures differ from novel structures?

Short stories and novels, while both forms of narrative fiction, employ distinctly different structural approaches due to their inherent differences in length, scope, and purpose. Understanding these differences is crucial for writers aiming to master both forms.

Scope and complexity:
Novels typically explore multiple plotlines, themes, and character arcs over an extended narrative. They have the luxury of space to develop complex worlds, intricate relationships, and nuanced character growth. Short stories, conversely, focus on a single plotline or theme, with a limited cast of characters and a more concentrated exploration of ideas.

Pacing:
The pacing in short stories is generally faster and more intense than in novels. Every scene in a short story must drive the narrative forward, while novels can afford more leisurely pacing, including subplots and diversions that enrich the overall story world.

Character development:
In novels, characters often undergo significant transformations over the course of the story. Short stories usually focus on a pivotal moment or realization in a character’s life, with development occurring through subtle shifts or epiphanies rather than extended arcs.

Time frame:
Novels frequently span extended periods, sometimes generations, allowing for expansive storytelling. Short stories often occur within a compressed timeframe, sometimes even a single day or moment, requiring a more focused narrative approach.

Structural elements:
While both forms can utilize similar structural elements (like exposition, rising action, climax, and resolution), their application differs significantly:

Structural Element Short Story Novel
Exposition Brief, often woven into the action Can be more extensive, with world-building and character introductions
Rising Action Rapid escalation of conflict Gradual build-up with multiple complications
Climax Single, powerful moment May have multiple climactic points
Resolution Swift, often open-ended More comprehensive, tying up multiple plot threads

Beginning and ending:
Short stories often start closer to the climax, immediately engaging the reader in the central conflict. Novels have more room for setup and can gradually introduce conflicts. Similarly, short story endings are typically more abrupt or open-ended, while novels tend to offer more complete resolutions.

Subplots:
Novels can sustain multiple subplots that interweave with the main narrative. Short stories rarely have room for subplots, focusing instead on a single narrative thread.

Symbolism and themes:
In short stories, symbolism and themes are often more concentrated and immediately apparent. Novels can develop themes more gradually and explore them from multiple angles.

Reader engagement:
Short stories aim to create a single, powerful emotional impact or intellectual insight. Novels seek to engage readers over a longer period, creating a more immersive experience.

Structural flexibility:
While both forms can experiment with structure, short stories often have more latitude for unconventional approaches due to their brevity. Novels, while capable of structural innovation, generally adhere more closely to traditional narrative arcs to maintain reader engagement over their longer span.

Understanding these structural differences is essential for writers transitioning between the two forms. It allows for the adaptation of storytelling techniques to suit the unique demands of each format, ensuring that whether crafting a brief, impactful tale or an expansive narrative journey, the structure serves the story’s ultimate purpose.

What are the core elements of short story structure?

The core elements of short story structure form the foundation upon which compelling narratives are built. These elements work in concert to create a cohesive, engaging story that resonates with readers long after the final sentence. Understanding and skillfully implementing these core elements is essential for crafting effective short fiction.

Exposition:
This element introduces the story’s setting, characters, and initial situation. In short stories, exposition is typically brief and often woven into the action to maintain a brisk pace. It provides just enough context for readers to understand the world of the story without bogging down the narrative.

Conflict:
The central problem or tension that drives the story forward. In short fiction, the conflict is usually singular and focused, providing the narrative with its primary source of tension and interest. It can be external (character vs. character, nature, or society) or internal (character vs. self).

Rising Action:
The series of events that build tension and complicate the conflict. In short stories, this phase is compressed, with each scene or event directly contributing to the escalation of the central conflict.

Climax:
The turning point of the story, where the conflict reaches its peak intensity. In short fiction, the climax is often a moment of revelation, decision, or action that fundamentally changes the protagonist or their situation.

Resolution:
The aftermath of the climax, showing how the conflict is resolved (or not resolved) and what this means for the characters. Short story resolutions are typically brief and may leave some aspects open to interpretation.

Character:
While not a structural element per se, character development is integral to short story structure. Characters in short fiction are often revealed through their actions and decisions rather than extensive backstory.

Setting:
The time and place where the story unfolds. In short stories, the setting is usually focused and plays a significant role in the story’s mood and conflict.

Theme:
The central idea or underlying meaning of the story. In short fiction, themes are often more concentrated and immediately apparent than in longer works.

Point of View:
The perspective from which the story is told. Short stories often employ a single, consistent point of view to maintain focus and intimacy.

Tone:
The overall mood or atmosphere of the story. In short fiction, establishing and maintaining a consistent tone is crucial for creating a unified reading experience.

These core elements interact in various ways to create the overall structure of a short story:

Element Function Interaction with Other Elements
Exposition Sets the stage Introduces characters and setting, hints at conflict
Conflict Drives the narrative Shapes character development, influences setting
Rising Action Builds tension Escalates conflict, reveals character
Climax Provides turning point Resolves conflict, tests character
Resolution Concludes the story Reflects on conflict, shows character change

While these elements are common to most short stories, their application can vary widely depending on the author’s style and the story’s specific needs. Some experimental short fiction may deliberately subvert or rearrange these elements to create unique narrative effects.

The skill in short story writing lies not just in including these elements, but in weaving them together seamlessly within the limited confines of the form. Each element should serve multiple purposes, contributing to plot development, character revelation, and thematic exploration simultaneously.

Mastering the core elements of short story structure allows writers to create narratives that are not only well-crafted but also emotionally resonant and intellectually satisfying. It’s the foundation upon which memorable short fiction is built, enabling authors to make the most of every word in their limited space.

How does Freytag’s Pyramid apply to short stories?

Freytag’s Pyramid, a classic model of dramatic structure, can be effectively applied to short stories, albeit with some adaptations to suit the more condensed format. This model, developed by 19th-century German novelist Gustav Freytag, provides a framework for understanding the rise and fall of dramatic tension in a narrative.

The traditional Freytag’s Pyramid consists of five parts:

Exposition: Introduction of characters, setting, and initial situation.
Rising Action: Development of conflict and complications.
Climax: The turning point or moment of greatest tension.
Falling Action: The consequences of the climax unfold.
Resolution (Denouement): The final outcome and tie-up of loose ends.

In applying Freytag’s Pyramid to short stories, it’s important to recognize that these elements often appear in a more compressed and intertwined form:

Exposition in Short Stories:
Short stories typically begin with minimal exposition, often starting in medias res (in the middle of things). Character backgrounds and setting details are revealed gradually through action and dialogue rather than extensive description.

Rising Action in Short Fiction:
The rising action in short stories is usually more rapid and focused than in longer works. Each scene or event directly contributes to the escalation of the central conflict, with little room for subplots or tangential developments.

Climax in Short Story Structure:
The climax in a short story is often more abrupt and impactful than in longer narratives. It frequently coincides with a moment of realization or change for the protagonist, serving as both the peak of tension and the catalyst for resolution.

Falling Action in Brief Narratives:
Due to the condensed nature of short stories, the falling action phase is often brief or even merged with the resolution. The consequences of the climax are quickly explored, leading directly to the story’s conclusion.

Resolution in Short Fiction:
Short story resolutions are typically swift and may leave some aspects open to interpretation. They often focus on the emotional or thematic impact of the events rather than tying up every loose end.

Adapting Freytag’s Pyramid for Short Stories:

Compression: All elements of the pyramid are condensed, with some potentially overlapping or merging.
Focus: Each element is more directly tied to the central conflict or theme.
Pacing: The rise and fall of tension occur more rapidly, with fewer plateaus or diversions.
Character Arc: Character development is often concentrated around a single significant change or realization.
Thematic Emphasis: The structure more explicitly serves the story’s central theme or message.

Here’s a comparison of how Freytag’s Pyramid might apply to a novel versus a short story:

Element Novel Application Short Story Application
Exposition Extended introduction of world and characters Brief, often woven into initial action
Rising Action Multiple complications and subplots Focused escalation of central conflict
Climax Extended sequence of events Single, pivotal moment
Falling Action Exploration of climax’s consequences Brief aftermath, often merged with resolution
Resolution Comprehensive tie-up of plot threads Swift conclusion, possibly open-ended

While Freytag’s Pyramid provides a useful framework for understanding narrative structure, it’s important to note that many successful short stories deviate from this model. Some may focus primarily on rising action with an abrupt or implied resolution, while others might explore a single moment in great depth, effectively expanding one part of the pyramid.

The value of applying Freytag’s Pyramid to short stories lies in its ability to help writers maintain narrative focus and tension. By understanding this structure, authors can ensure that each element of their story serves a clear purpose in the overall narrative arc, even within the constraints of the short form.

Ultimately, the application of Freytag’s Pyramid to short stories should be flexible, serving as a guide rather than a rigid template. The most effective short stories use structural elements creatively, adapting them to serve the unique needs of each narrative while maintaining the emotional and thematic impact that makes short fiction so powerful.

What is the Three-Act Structure in short fiction?

The Three-Act Structure, a widely used narrative model in various forms of storytelling, can be effectively applied to short fiction, offering a clear and concise framework for organizing a story’s plot. This structure divides the narrative into three distinct sections: Setup, Confrontation, and Resolution. When adapted for short stories, the Three-Act Structure provides a streamlined approach to storytelling that maintains narrative momentum within a limited word count.

Act One: Setup
In short fiction, the first act is typically brief but crucial. It serves to:

Introduce the protagonist and other key characters
Establish the story’s setting and tone
Present the inciting incident that sets the main conflict in motion
Hook the reader with an engaging opening

The setup in a short story must be efficient, often combining character introduction with the inciting incident to immediately engage the reader.

Act Two: Confrontation
This act forms the bulk of the short story, focusing on:

Developing the central conflict
Presenting obstacles and complications for the protagonist
Revealing character through actions and decisions
Building tension towards the climax

In short fiction, the second act is more compressed than in longer works, with each scene directly contributing to the escalation of the main conflict.

Act Three: Resolution
The final act in a short story is typically brief but impactful, including:

The climax, where the conflict reaches its peak
The resolution of the main conflict
A brief denouement, showing the aftermath of the climax
Potentially, a final twist or revelation

Short story resolutions often leave some aspects open to interpretation, focusing on the emotional or thematic impact rather than tying up every loose end.

Adapting the Three-Act Structure for Short Fiction:

Compression: Each act is condensed, with Act Two typically being the longest.
Focused Conflict: The central conflict is usually singular and clearly defined.
Rapid Pacing: Transitions between acts are often swift and seamless.
Character Arc: Character development is concentrated around the main conflict.
Thematic Clarity: The structure supports a clear thematic statement or question.

Here’s a comparison of how the Three-Act Structure might be applied in a novel versus a short story:

Act Novel Application Short Story Application
Setup Extended world-building and character introduction Brief introduction, often combined with inciting incident
Confrontation Multiple subplots and character arcs Focused development of central conflict
Resolution Comprehensive resolution of all plot threads Swift conclusion, often with thematic emphasis

Benefits of Using the Three-Act Structure in Short Fiction:

Clarity: Provides a clear roadmap for the story’s progression.
Focus: Helps maintain narrative focus on the central conflict.
Pacing: Ensures a well-paced story with rising tension.
Character Development: Structures character growth around the main conflict.
Reader Engagement: Creates a familiar rhythm that keeps readers invested.

Challenges and Considerations:

Avoiding Formulaic Writing: While the structure is helpful, it shouldn’t be applied rigidly at the expense of creativity.
Balancing Acts: In short fiction, the acts may not be evenly distributed, with Act Two often taking up the majority of the story.
Seamless Transitions: The limited word count requires smooth transitions between acts to maintain flow.
Subverting Expectations: Some effective short stories deliberately play with or subvert this structure for artistic effect.

Examples in Classic Short Fiction:

“The Gift of the Magi” by O. Henry:
Act One introduces the poor couple and their desire to buy gifts.
Act Two shows their individual sacrifices.
Act Three reveals the ironic outcome and thematic message.

“The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson:
Act One sets up the seemingly normal village gathering.
Act Two builds tension through the lottery process.
Act Three delivers the shocking climax and resolution.

The Three-Act Structure in short fiction serves as a valuable tool for writers, providing a framework that ensures narrative cohesion and emotional impact within the constraints of the form. It helps in crafting stories that feel complete and satisfying, even in their brevity. However, it’s important for writers to use this structure as a guide rather than a rigid formula, adapting it to serve the unique needs of each story and maintaining the creative spark that makes short fiction so compelling.

How does the ABDCE model work for short stories?

The ABDCE model, popularized by author Alice Adams and further disseminated by Anne Lamott in her book “Bird by Bird,” offers a unique approach to structuring short stories. This model provides a framework that is particularly well-suited to the concise nature of short fiction. ABDCE stands for Action, Background, Development, Climax, and Ending. Let’s explore how this model works for short stories and its implications for crafting compelling narratives.

Action:
The story begins with an immediate action or scene that hooks the reader. This opening should be engaging and provide a glimpse into the story’s central conflict or theme.

In short stories, this initial action is crucial. It often serves multiple purposes:
Introducing the protagonist
Establishing the tone and setting
Hinting at the central conflict

Background:
After the initial action, the story provides necessary context. This background information helps readers understand the characters, their motivations, and the situation they’re in.

In short fiction, background is typically woven into the narrative rather than presented as a separate block of exposition. It might include:
Brief character histories
Essential setting details
Information about relationships or past events

Development:
This section forms the bulk of the story, where the conflict unfolds and characters evolve. In short stories, development is tightly focused on the central conflict or theme.

Key aspects of development in short fiction include:
Escalating tension
Character choices and their consequences
Revealing character through action and dialogue

Climax:
The turning point of the story, where the conflict reaches its peak intensity. In short stories, the climax is often a moment of revelation or decision that fundamentally changes the protagonist or their situation.

Characteristics of climax in short fiction:
Often occurs near the end of the story
May be subtle or dramatic, depending on the story’s tone
Typically involves a significant change or realization

Ending:
The resolution of the story, showing the aftermath of the climax and its implications for the characters. Short story endings are often brief but impactful.

Elements of effective short story endings:
Provide closure to the central conflict
Reflect on the story’s theme
May leave some aspects open to interpretation

Applying the ABDCE Model to Short Stories:

Compression: Each element is condensed to fit the short story format.
Integration: Elements often overlap or blend seamlessly.
Focus: Every part of the model serves the central conflict or theme.
Pacing: The model helps maintain narrative momentum throughout the story.

Here’s a comparison of how the ABDCE model might be applied in different story lengths:

Element Flash Fiction (< 1000 words) Short Story (1000-7500 words) Novella (7500-40000 words)
Action Single opening sentence or paragraph Brief opening scene Extended opening sequence
Background Minimal, implied through action Woven throughout narrative More extensive, with potential flashbacks
Development Focused on a single moment or decision Explores central conflict Multiple subplots and character arcs
Climax Often coincides with ending Near the end, distinct from resolution Extended sequence of events
Ending Abrupt, often open-ended Brief but impactful More comprehensive resolution

Benefits of Using the ABDCE Model in Short Fiction:

Immediate Engagement: Starting with action hooks readers from the first sentence.
Narrative Clarity: The model provides a clear structure for organizing story elements.
Character Focus: Emphasizes character development through action and conflict.
Thematic Coherence: Helps maintain focus on the central theme or idea.
Efficient Storytelling: Encourages concise, purposeful writing suited to short fiction.

Challenges and Considerations:

Balancing Elements: Ensuring each part of the model receives appropriate attention within the limited word count.
Avoiding Predictability: Using the model as a guide rather than a rigid formula to maintain creativity.
Seamless Transitions: Blending elements smoothly to maintain narrative flow.
Adapting to Story Needs: Recognizing when a story might benefit from deviating from the model.

The ABDCE model offers a valuable framework for crafting short stories, providing a structure that aligns well with the demands of concise storytelling. It encourages writers to engage readers immediately, provide necessary context efficiently, develop the story’s conflict and characters purposefully, build to a meaningful climax, and conclude with impact. By understanding and skillfully applying this model, writers can create short fiction that is both structurally sound and emotionally resonant.

What makes an effective short story beginning?

An effective short story beginning is crucial for capturing readers’ attention and setting the tone for the entire narrative. In the limited space of a short story, the opening lines or paragraphs carry significant weight, often determining whether a reader will continue or set the story aside. Let’s explore the elements that contribute to a compelling short story beginning.

Immediate Engagement:
The most effective short story openings plunge readers directly into the action or the heart of the conflict. This approach, known as in medias res (into the middle of things), creates immediate intrigue and momentum.

Techniques for immediate engagement include:
Starting with dialogue
Opening with a provocative statement
Beginning with a vivid sensory description
Presenting an unusual or intriguing situation

Character Introduction:
Effective beginnings quickly introduce the protagonist or main character in a way that makes readers care about their fate. This doesn’t necessarily mean providing a full character description, but rather giving a sense of who the character is and what drives them.

Methods of character introduction:
Showing the character in action
Revealing the character’s thoughts or emotions
Presenting a defining characteristic or quirk

Setting Establishment:
The opening should swiftly establish the story’s setting, providing readers with a sense of time and place. This context helps ground the narrative and can contribute to the overall mood or atmosphere of the story.

Approaches to setting establishment:
Vivid sensory details
Subtle references to time period or location
Atmosphere-building descriptions

Conflict Hint:
While the full nature of the conflict may not be immediately apparent, effective beginnings often hint at the central tension or problem that will drive the story.

Ways to hint at conflict:
Introducing a problem or obstacle
Showing character unease or dissatisfaction
Presenting a mysterious element or unanswered question

Tone Setting:
The opening lines set the tone for the entire story, whether it’s humorous, melancholic, suspenseful, or contemplative. This tone should align with the overall mood and theme of the narrative.

Elements that contribute to tone:
Word choice and sentence structure
Narrative voice (first person, third person, etc.)
Pacing and rhythm of the prose

Thematic Resonance:
Strong beginnings often introduce or allude to the story’s central theme, providing a foundation for the thematic exploration that will unfold.

Methods of introducing themes:
Symbolic imagery
Thought-provoking statements
Juxtaposition of contrasting elements

Here’s a comparison of effective opening techniques for different genres of short fiction:

Genre Opening Technique Example
Literary Lyrical description “The sky above the port was the color of television, tuned to a dead channel.” – William Gibson, “Neuromancer”
Mystery Intriguing situation “I was arrested in Eno’s diner.” – Lee Child, “Killing Floor”
Horror Unsettling atmosphere “The last thing I wanted was to move into a haunted house.” – Shirley Jackson, “The Haunting of Hill House”
Romance Character introduction “It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a wife.” – Jane Austen, “Pride and Prejudice”

Characteristics of Ineffective Beginnings:

Excessive exposition or background information
Clichéd or overly familiar openings
Vague or confusing language
Lack of connection to the story’s central conflict or theme

Strategies for Crafting Effective Beginnings:

Start as close to the inciting incident as possible
Use strong, specific language to create vivid imagery
Introduce a question or mystery that compels readers to seek answers
Establish a unique voice or perspective
Create tension or conflict from the first line

Revision Techniques:

Write multiple versions of the opening and compare their effectiveness
Read the beginning aloud to assess its rhythm and impact
Get feedback from beta readers on their initial impressions
Analyze the openings of successful short stories in your genre

The art of crafting an effective short story beginning lies in striking a balance between providing enough information to orient the reader and maintaining an air of mystery or intrigue that compels them to read on. It requires careful consideration of the story’s core elements – character, setting, conflict, and theme – and how they can be introduced most effectively within the opening lines or paragraphs.

A strong beginning sets the stage for the entire narrative, establishing the story’s world, introducing its characters, and hinting at the journey to come. It’s the writer’s first and often only chance to capture the reader’s imagination and draw them into the story. By mastering the craft of effective beginnings, short story writers can create openings that not only hook readers but also lay the foundation for memorable and impactful narratives.

How can writers develop compelling rising action?

Developing compelling rising action is crucial for maintaining reader engagement and building tension in short stories. This phase of the narrative, where the central conflict unfolds and complications arise, forms the backbone of the story’s dramatic structure. Here’s how writers can craft effective rising action in short fiction:

Escalating Conflict:
The core of compelling rising action is the escalation of the central conflict. Each scene or event should increase the stakes or add complexity to the protagonist’s situation.

Techniques for escalating conflict:
Introducing new obstacles or challenges
Revealing hidden aspects of the conflict
Raising the personal stakes for the protagonist

Character Development:
Rising action provides opportunities for character growth and revelation. As characters face increasing challenges, their true nature and motivations become apparent.

Methods of character development:
Forcing difficult decisions
Revealing character flaws or strengths
Exploring relationships under pressure

Pacing:
In short stories, pacing is particularly crucial. The rising action should maintain a steady increase in tension without feeling rushed or dragging.

Strategies for effective pacing:
Varying sentence and paragraph length
Alternating between action and reflection
Using dialogue to advance the plot and reveal character

Foreshadowing:
Subtle hints about future events or the story’s climax can create anticipation and deepen reader engagement.

Ways to incorporate foreshadowing:
Symbolic imagery
Seemingly insignificant details that gain importance later
Character predictions or fears

Complications and Reversals:
Introducing unexpected twists or setbacks keeps the narrative dynamic and unpredictable.

Types of complications:
New information that changes the protagonist’s understanding
Unforeseen consequences of the character’s actions
External events that impact the main conflict

Thematic Development:
The rising action should contribute to the exploration of the story’s central theme or idea.

Approaches to thematic development:
Presenting different perspectives on the theme
Challenging the protagonist’s beliefs or values
Showing the theme’s impact on various characters

Here’s a comparison of rising action techniques in different short story genres:

Genre Rising Action Technique Example
Mystery Revealing clues and red herrings Gradually uncovering evidence while introducing misleading information
Romance Developing relationship obstacles Creating misunderstandings or external pressures that keep the couple apart
Horror Building atmospheric tension Slowly revealing the true nature of the threat while increasing the sense of danger
Science Fiction Exploring consequences of a concept Showing how a scientific or technological idea impacts characters and society

Balancing Elements in Rising Action:

Action vs. Reflection: Alternating between external events and internal character responses
Plot Advancement vs. Character Development: Ensuring that plot events also reveal character
Main Plot vs. Subplots: In short stories, subplots should be minimal and closely tied to the main conflict

Techniques for Maintaining Tension:

Ticking Clock: Introducing a time limit or deadline
Raising Questions: Posing new mysteries or uncertainties
Withholding Information: Strategically delaying key revelations
Contrasting Moments: Juxtaposing calm scenes with high-tension events

Common Pitfalls in Rising Action:

Introducing irrelevant complications
Overexplaining or excessive exposition
Predictable or clichéd plot developments
Losing focus on the central conflict

Revision Strategies for Strengthening Rising Action:

Analyze each scene for its contribution to the overall conflict
Ensure a clear progression of events and emotional intensity
Check for consistent character motivation and behavior
Trim any elements that don’t directly serve the main story arc

The key to developing compelling rising action in short stories lies in maintaining a delicate balance. Each element introduced should serve multiple purposes: advancing the plot, developing characters, exploring themes, and building towards the climax. In the limited space of a short story, every word and scene must contribute to the overall narrative tension.

Effective rising action creates a sense of inevitability while still surprising the reader. It should feel like a natural progression of events, each flowing logically from the last, yet with enough unpredictability to keep readers engaged. By mastering the art of rising action, writers can create short stories that are not just read, but experienced, drawing readers inexorably towards a satisfying and impactful conclusion.

What characterizes a strong climax in a short story?

A strong climax is the pinnacle of a short story, the moment where tensions peak and the central conflict reaches its most intense point. It’s the narrative fulcrum upon which the entire story balances, often providing the key to the story’s meaning or theme. In short fiction, where every word counts, the climax carries particular weight. Let’s explore the characteristics that define a powerful climax in a short story.

Intensity and Impact:
The climax should represent the highest point of tension or conflict in the story. It’s where the stakes are at their peak and the outcome hangs in the balance.

Elements of intensity:
Emotional crescendo
Physical or psychological danger
Moment of ultimate decision or revelation

Resolution of Central Conflict:
While the full resolution may come after, the climax should directly address or bring to a head the story’s main conflict.

Approaches to conflict resolution:
Confrontation between opposing forces
Internal realization or change
Revelation of crucial information

Character Transformation:
The climax often marks a turning point for the protagonist, challenging them to change or revealing their true nature.

Types of character moments:
Moral choices
Overcoming (or succumbing to) personal flaws
Moments of self-realization

Thematic Culmination:
A strong climax should embody or illuminate the story’s central theme or message.

Methods of thematic expression:
Symbolic actions or imagery
Dialogue that encapsulates the theme
Situations that test the theme’s validity

Surprise or Inevitability:
Effective climaxes often balance a sense of surprise with a feeling of inevitability. They should be unexpected yet feel like the natural culmination of the story’s events.

Balancing surprise and inevitability:
Subverting reader expectations
Fulfilling foreshadowing in unexpected ways
Revealing hidden aspects of characters or situations

Brevity and Focus:
In short stories, the climax is often brief but potent. It should be tightly focused on the core elements of the conflict and character arc.

Techniques for concise climaxes:
Minimizing extraneous details
Concentrating on key actions or dialogue
Using powerful, evocative language

Here’s a comparison of climax characteristics in different short story genres:

Genre Climax Characteristic Example
Mystery Revelation of truth Detective confronts the murderer, revealing the solution to the puzzle
Romance Emotional culmination Lovers overcome final obstacle and commit to each other
Horror Peak of terror or revelation Protagonist faces the monster or understands the true nature of the threat
Literary Moment of profound insight Character experiences an epiphany that changes their worldview

Elements of an Effective Climax:

Logical Progression: The climax should feel like a natural result of preceding events
Emotional Resonance: It should evoke strong feelings in both characters and readers
Clarity: The core conflict or question should be clearly addressed
Memorability: The scene should leave a lasting impression

Common Pitfalls in Crafting Climaxes:

Anticlimactic resolutions that fail to meet built-up expectations
Introducing new elements that weren’t previously established
Overcomplicating the moment with unnecessary details
Rushing through the climax without giving it proper weight

Techniques for Strengthening Climaxes:

Foreshadowing: Plant seeds earlier in the story that come to fruition in the climax
Pacing: Build rhythm and tension leading up to the climactic moment
Sensory Details: Use vivid descriptions to make the scene immersive
Dialogue: Craft powerful exchanges that encapsulate character conflicts

Revision Strategies for Climaxes:

Analyze the climax’s connection to the story’s central question or conflict
Ensure the protagonist plays an active role in the climactic events
Check that the climax aligns with and illuminates the story’s theme
Consider the emotional impact on both characters and readers

The climax in a short story serves as the narrative and emotional peak, the moment where all the story’s elements converge. It should provide a sense of catharsis or revelation, offering readers the payoff for their investment in the characters and conflict. In the limited space of a short story, the climax often needs to do doubleor triple duty, resolving conflicts, revealing character, and illuminating themes simultaneously.

A strong climax in a short story leaves readers with a sense of satisfaction, even if all questions aren’t fully answered. It should feel both surprising and inevitable, a delicate balance that comes from careful crafting of the preceding narrative. By mastering the art of creating powerful climaxes, short story writers can ensure their tales resonate long after the final word is read.

How should writers approach resolution in short fiction?

Resolution in short fiction, often referred to as denouement, is the final phase of the narrative where the story’s tensions are released and loose ends are addressed. In the limited space of a short story, the approach to resolution requires careful consideration and skillful execution. Here’s how writers can effectively craft resolutions in short fiction:

Brevity and Impact:
Short story resolutions are typically brief but potent. They should provide a sense of closure while leaving a lasting impression on the reader.

Techniques for impactful resolutions:
Focusing on emotional or thematic resonance
Using powerful imagery or symbolism
Ending with a memorable line or image

Addressing the Central Conflict:
The resolution should provide a clear outcome to the story’s main conflict, even if that outcome is deliberately ambiguous.

Approaches to conflict resolution:
Definitive resolution of the problem
Character acceptance of an unresolved situation
Transformation of the conflict into a new understanding

Character Arc Completion:
Show how the protagonist has changed or what they’ve learned as a result of the story’s events.

Methods of demonstrating character growth:
Contrasting final actions with earlier behavior
Revealing new insights or perspectives
Showing the character’s adjusted worldview

Thematic Reinforcement:
The resolution should reinforce or provide final commentary on the story’s central theme.

Ways to emphasize themes:
Symbolic actions that embody the theme
Dialogue that encapsulates the story’s message
Situations that demonstrate the theme’s implications

Open-Ended vs. Closed Endings:
Short stories can effectively use either open-ended or closed resolutions, depending on the story’s goals and themes.

Characteristics of different ending types:
Open-ended: Leaves room for interpretation, invites reader reflection
Closed: Provides clear answers, offers a sense of completeness

Avoiding Overexplanation:
In short fiction, it’s often more effective to imply rather than explicitly state all outcomes.

Strategies for subtle resolutions:
Using subtext in dialogue or actions
Leaving some elements to the reader’s imagination
Focusing on key details rather than comprehensive explanations

Here’s a comparison of resolution approaches in different types of short stories:

Story Type Resolution Approach Example
Twist Ending Revelation that recontextualizes the entire story O. Henry’s “The Gift of the Magi”
Circular Narrative Ending that echoes or returns to the beginning James Joyce’s “The Dead”
Epiphany Story Character’s moment of profound realization Katherine Mansfield’s “The Garden Party”
Ambiguous Ending Deliberately unclear or open to interpretation Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery”

Elements of Effective Resolutions:

Emotional Satisfaction: Providing a sense of emotional completion, even if all questions aren’t answered
Logical Consistency: Ensuring the ending aligns with the story’s internal logic
Proportionality: Matching the tone and scale of the resolution to the rest of the story
Memorability: Crafting an ending that lingers in the reader’s mind

Common Pitfalls in Crafting Resolutions:

Deus ex machina endings that feel contrived or unearned
Overly neat resolutions that tie up every loose end
Abrupt endings that fail to provide any sense of closure
Moralizing or heavy-handed delivery of the story’s message

Techniques for Strengthening Resolutions:

Echoing: Referencing earlier elements of the story for a sense of completion
Contrast: Highlighting changes by contrasting the ending with the beginning
Implications: Suggesting future consequences beyond the story’s scope
Resonance: Ending on an emotionally or thematically resonant note

Revision Strategies for Resolutions:

Analyze how the resolution relates to the story’s opening and central conflict
Ensure the protagonist’s final state or action reflects their journey
Check that the ending aligns with and reinforces the story’s theme
Consider the emotional impact and lasting impression on the reader

The resolution in a short story serves as the final brushstroke in the narrative painting. It should provide a sense of completion while often leaving room for reader reflection. In the constrained format of short fiction, resolutions need to be particularly nuanced, offering closure without overexplaining or diminishing the impact of the preceding narrative.

Effective resolutions in short stories often resonate beyond the confines of the tale itself, inviting readers to ponder the implications of the narrative long after they’ve finished reading. By mastering the art of crafting powerful resolutions, writers can ensure their short fiction leaves a lasting impression, encouraging readers to revisit and reinterpret the story in their minds.

What are common structural variations in short stories?

While traditional narrative structures like Freytag’s Pyramid or the Three-Act Structure are widely used, short stories often employ various structural variations to create unique and impactful narratives. These alternative structures can help writers break free from conventional storytelling patterns and explore new ways of engaging readers. Here are some common structural variations found in short fiction:

Circular Narrative:
This structure begins and ends at the same point, creating a loop in the story.

Characteristics:
Events come full circle
Ending echoes or directly mirrors the beginning
Often used to emphasize themes of repetition or inevitability

Frame Narrative:
A story within a story, where a main narrative encloses one or more other narratives.

Elements:
Outer story that introduces or contextualizes the inner story
Inner story that forms the main plot
Connection between the two narratives that adds depth or meaning

Vignette Structure:
A series of brief, interconnected scenes or moments rather than a traditional plot arc.

Features:
Focus on mood, character, or theme rather than plot
Often non-chronological or loosely connected events
Emphasis on sensory details and impressions

Reverse Chronology:
The story is told backwards, starting with the end and moving towards the beginning.

Techniques:
Reveals cause after effect
Creates suspense through gradual revelation of past events
Often used to explore themes of memory or consequence

Parallel Narratives:
Multiple storylines that run concurrently, often intersecting or influencing each other.

Approaches:
Alternating between different characters’ perspectives
Showing same events from different viewpoints
Connecting seemingly unrelated stories thematically

Fragmented or Mosaic Structure:
The narrative is broken into distinct, often non-chronological pieces that the reader must assemble.

Characteristics:
Non-linear presentation of events
Use of different narrative styles or formats within one story
Requires active reader engagement to construct meaning

Here’s a comparison of how these structural variations might be applied in short stories:

Structure Application Example Story
Circular Story begins and ends with same scene “The Monkey’s Paw” by W.W. Jacobs
Frame Main story told within context of another “The Thousand and One Nights”
Vignette Series of loosely connected scenes “In Our Time” by Ernest Hemingway
Reverse Chronology Events narrated from end to beginning “Betrayal” by Harold Pinter
Parallel Narratives Multiple intersecting storylines “The Joy Luck Club” by Amy Tan
Fragmented Non-linear, pieced-together narrative “Girl” by Jamaica Kincaid

Benefits of Structural Variations:

Freshness: Breaks away from predictable narrative patterns
Thematic Reinforcement: Structure can reflect or emphasize the story’s themes
Reader Engagement: Encourages active participation in constructing the narrative
Emotional Impact: Can create unique emotional responses or insights

Challenges in Using Alternative Structures:

Maintaining clarity and coherence
Ensuring reader engagement without confusion
Balancing experimental structure with satisfying storytelling
Avoiding gimmickry or structure for structure’s sake

Techniques for Effective Use of Structural Variations:

Establish clear patterns or rules for the chosen structure
Use transitional devices to guide readers through the narrative
Ensure the structure serves the story’s themes or emotional core
Balance innovative structure with familiar narrative elements

Revision Strategies for Unconventional Structures:

Analyze how the structure contributes to the story’s overall impact
Ensure each structural element serves a purpose in the narrative
Test the story on beta readers to gauge clarity and effectiveness
Consider whether a more traditional structure might better serve the story

When employing structural variations in short stories, it’s crucial to remember that the structure should serve the story, not vice versa. The chosen structure should enhance the narrative’s themes, characters, or emotional resonance rather than existing as a mere technical exercise.

These alternative structures offer writers tools to create unique reading experiences, challenge reader expectations, and explore complex themes or emotions in innovative ways. By mastering various structural approaches, short story writers can expand their storytelling repertoire and craft narratives that stand out in their originality and impact.

How is structure adapted for flash fiction?

Flash fiction, typically defined as stories under 1,000 words (with some variations going as low as 100 words), requires a unique approach to narrative structure. The extreme brevity of this form demands a distillation of storytelling elements, often leading to innovative structural adaptations. Here’s how structure is typically adapted for flash fiction:

Compressed Narrative Arc:
Flash fiction often compresses the traditional story arc into its barest essentials.

Techniques for compression:
Focusing on a single moment or turning point
Implying broader context through minimal details
Using the title as an integral part of the story

Immediate Engagement:
With no space for gradual build-up, flash fiction must hook readers instantly.

Strategies for immediate engagement:
Starting in medias res (in the middle of the action)
Opening with a provocative statement or image
Beginning with dialogue that implies conflict or tension

Implied Exposition:
Background information is often suggested rather than explicitly stated.

Methods of implying exposition:
Using specific details that hint at a larger context
Relying on readers’ general knowledge or assumptions
Incorporating backstory through brief, pointed references

Concentrated Character Development:
Characters are typically revealed through a single defining action or trait.

Approaches to character development in flash fiction:
Focusing on a character’s crucial decision or realization
Using telling details to imply personality and history
Revealing character through interaction with the setting or other characters

Economical Use of Language:
Every word must serve multiple purposes in flash fiction.

Techniques for linguistic economy:
Using evocative, multi-layered imagery
Employing subtext in dialogue and description
Choosing words with rich connotations

Here’s a comparison of structural elements in traditional short stories versus flash fiction:

Element Traditional Short Story Flash Fiction
Exposition Dedicated section or woven throughout Implied or minimal
Rising Action Series of events building tension Often a single pivotal moment
Climax Clear turning point or peak of conflict May coincide with the ending
Resolution Distinct phase addressing consequences Often implied or left open
Character Development Gradual reveal through multiple scenes Snapshot or single defining moment

Common Structural Approaches in Flash Fiction:

Vignette: A brief, evocative scene that implies a larger story
Twist Ending: Building to a surprising revelation in the final lines
Circular Structure: Ending that echoes or directly connects to the opening
Fragmented Narrative: Piecing together disparate elements to suggest a whole
Single Scene: Focusing entirely on one moment or interaction

Challenges in Structuring Flash Fiction:

Creating a complete narrative arc in extremely limited space
Balancing brevity with depth and resonance
Avoiding confusion while maintaining intrigue
Resisting the urge to overexplain or include unnecessary details

Techniques for Effective Flash Fiction Structure:

Use the title to provide context or set up the story
Employ strong, specific imagery to convey mood and setting quickly
Focus on a single conflict, theme, or emotional beat
Use white space and formatting to create pacing and emphasis

Revision Strategies for Flash Fiction:

Analyze every word for its contribution to the overall story
Ensure the opening line and ending create a satisfying frame
Check that implied elements are clear enough for reader understanding
Consider multiple interpretations and adjust for desired ambiguity or clarity

Flash fiction structure often relies heavily on implication and reader participation. The limited word count means that much of the story may exist “between the lines,” with readers filling in gaps based on carefully chosen details and suggestions. This collaborative aspect of flash fiction can create a uniquely engaging reading experience.

The adaptation of structure for flash fiction is an exercise in narrative efficiency and precision. It challenges writers to distill storytelling to its essence, creating complete and impactful narratives in the smallest possible space. Mastering flash fiction structure can sharpen a writer’s skills in concision, implication, and narrative focus, benefiting their writing across all forms and lengths.

What are the most common structural pitfalls in short stories?

Even experienced writers can fall into structural traps when crafting short stories. Recognizing and avoiding these common pitfalls is crucial for creating compelling and effective narratives. Here are some of the most frequent structural issues encountered in short fiction:

Weak or Unclear Conflict:
The central conflict drives the story and engages readers. Without a clear, compelling conflict, the narrative can feel aimless or unengaging.

Signs of weak conflict:
Lack of tension or stakes
Conflict that doesn’t relate to character goals or motivations
Resolution that comes too easily or without character effort

Uneven Pacing:
Pacing issues can disrupt the flow of the story and reader engagement.

Common pacing problems:
Slow start with too much exposition
Rushed ending that feels abrupt or unsatisfying
Middle section that drags or loses focus

Underdeveloped Characters:
In short fiction, characters need to be quickly established and developed to engage readers.

Character development issues:
Flat or stereotypical characters
Lack of character growth or change
Inconsistent character behavior

Overwriting:
Excessive detail or flowery prose can bog down a short story.

Signs of overwriting:
Unnecessary descriptions that don’t advance the plot or reveal character
Overuse of adjectives and adverbs
Dialogue that’s too on-the-nose or expository

Lack of Thematic Focus:
Short stories benefit from a clear thematic thread that ties the narrative together.

Thematic pitfalls:
Multiple competing themes that dilute the story’s impact
Lack of thematic relevance to the plot or characters
Heavy-handed or preachy thematic statements

Here’s a comparison of structural elements in well-executed versus problematic short stories:

Element Well-Executed Problematic
Opening Hooks reader, establishes tone Slow, confusing, or irrelevant
Conflict Clear, compelling, character-driven Vague, low-stakes, or disconnected from characters
Character Development Efficient, revealing, consistent Flat, stereotypical, or inconsistent
Pacing Balanced, maintains tension Uneven, drags or rushes
Ending Satisfying, resonant Abrupt, disconnected, or anticlimactic

Additional Common Structural Pitfalls:

Unnecessary Subplots: Introducing storylines that don’t contribute to the main narrative
Lack of Causality: Events that don’t logically follow from previous occurrences
Inconsistent Point of View: Shifting perspectives without clear purpose or control
Misplaced Climax: Positioning the story’s peak too early or too late in the narrative
Unfocused Narrative: Lack of a clear through-line or central question driving the story

Consequences of Structural Pitfalls:

Reader disengagement
Confusion or frustration with the narrative
Lack of emotional impact or resonance
Difficulty in conveying themes or messages effectively

Techniques for Avoiding Structural Pitfalls:

Outline the story to ensure a clear narrative arc
Focus on a single, compelling conflict
Develop characters through action and dialogue rather than exposition
Ruthlessly edit for concision and relevance
Ensure each scene serves multiple purposes (plot advancement, character development, thematic exploration)

Revision Strategies to Address Structural Issues:

Analyze the story’s structure using a visual diagram or outline
Get feedback from beta readers on pacing and engagement
Read the story aloud to catch pacing and dialogue issues
Consider alternative structures that might better serve the story

Recognizing and addressing these common structural pitfalls is essential for crafting effective short stories. It requires a balance of creativity and technical skill, as well as a willingness to revise and refine the narrative. By avoiding these issues, writers can create short fiction that engages readers, conveys themes effectively, and leaves a lasting impact.

Understanding these pitfalls also helps writers develop a critical eye for their own work and that of others. It’s part of the ongoing process of honing one’s craft, learning to see the underlying structure ofa story and how it supports or undermines the narrative’s goals. By mastering the structural elements of short fiction, writers can create stories that are not only well-crafted but also emotionally resonant and thematically rich.

How can writers analyze short story structures?

Analyzing short story structures is a valuable skill for both writers and readers. It allows for a deeper understanding of how narratives work and can significantly improve one’s own writing. Here are effective methods for analyzing short story structures:

Plot Mapping:
Create a visual representation of the story’s plot to understand its structure.

Techniques for plot mapping:
Identify key plot points (inciting incident, rising action, climax, resolution)
Note the placement of these points within the story
Analyze the balance and pacing between different sections

Character Arc Analysis:
Examine how characters develop and change throughout the story.

Aspects to consider:
Initial state of the character
Key moments of change or decision
Final state and how it relates to the story’s theme

Conflict Identification:
Pinpoint the central conflict and how it evolves.

Elements to analyze:
Nature of the conflict (internal, external, man vs. nature, etc.)
Introduction and escalation of the conflict
Resolution or transformation of the conflict

Thematic Exploration:
Identify the story’s central theme(s) and how they are developed.

Approaches to thematic analysis:
Note recurring motifs or symbols
Examine how different characters relate to the theme
Analyze how the theme influences plot decisions

Narrative Perspective Study:
Examine the point of view and its impact on the story.

Factors to consider:
Narrative voice (first person, third person, etc.)
Reliability of the narrator
Shifts in perspective and their purpose

Language and Style Analysis:
Explore how the author’s writing style contributes to the story’s structure.

Elements to analyze:
Sentence structure and length
Use of literary devices (metaphor, foreshadowing, etc.)
Dialogue and its role in advancing the plot or revealing character

Here’s a comparison of structural elements across different short story genres:

Element Literary Fiction Genre Fiction (e.g., Mystery) Experimental Fiction
Plot Often character-driven Plot-driven, clear arc May subvert traditional plot structures
Character Development Central focus Serves the plot May be minimal or unconventional
Conflict Often internal or subtle Clear external conflict May be abstract or meta-textual
Theme Explored through subtext Often tied to genre conventions May be the primary focus of experimentation
Resolution Often open-ended or ambiguous Clear resolution of central conflict May deliberately avoid resolution

Techniques for Effective Structure Analysis:

Close Reading: Carefully examine the text, noting structural elements and their effects
Comparative Analysis: Compare the structure to other stories or established models
Reverse Outlining: Create an outline of the story after reading to understand its structure
Scene Breakdown: Analyze individual scenes for their contribution to the overall structure
Dialogue Analysis: Examine how dialogue advances the plot or reveals character

Tools for Structural Analysis:

Story structure templates (e.g., Freytag’s Pyramid, Three-Act Structure)
Character development charts
Conflict maps
Thematic webs
Timeline diagrams

Benefits of Analyzing Short Story Structures:

Improved understanding of narrative techniques
Enhanced ability to identify strengths and weaknesses in stories
Development of a critical eye for one’s own writing
Increased appreciation for the craft of storytelling

Applying Analysis to Writing:

Use insights from analysis to plan and outline new stories
Identify areas for improvement in your own writing
Experiment with different structural approaches
Develop a personal style informed by structural understanding

By systematically analyzing short story structures, writers can gain valuable insights into the craft of storytelling. This analytical approach not only enhances one’s ability to appreciate and critique literature but also provides practical tools for improving one’s own writing. Understanding the underlying structures of successful stories allows writers to make informed choices about plot, character development, pacing, and thematic exploration in their own work.

What exercises help in mastering short story structure?

Mastering short story structure requires practice and deliberate skill development. Here are several exercises that can help writers improve their understanding and application of short story structure:

Story Skeleton Exercise:
Write a complete short story using only plot points and key structural elements.

Steps:
Outline a basic story arc (setup, conflict, climax, resolution)
Write one sentence for each major plot point
Expand each sentence into a paragraph, focusing on structural flow

Genre Flip:
Take a familiar story and rewrite it in a different genre, focusing on structural changes.

Process:
Choose a well-known story (e.g., a fairy tale)
Select a new genre (e.g., sci-fi, romance, horror)
Rewrite the story, adapting the structure to fit the new genre

Timed Writing Sprints:
Practice writing complete short stories within strict time limits.

Variations:
15-minute flash fiction challenge
30-minute short story sprint
One-hour structured story writing

Reverse Engineering:
Analyze the structure of published short stories and recreate them with new content.

Steps:
Choose a short story you admire
Break down its structure into key components
Write a new story following the same structural pattern

Character-Driven Plotting:
Create a story structure based entirely on character decisions and growth.

Approach:
Start with a well-defined character
List potential decisions the character could make
Build a plot structure around these decisions and their consequences

Here’s a comparison of exercises focusing on different structural elements:

Exercise Focus Benefit
Story Skeleton Overall arc Strengthens understanding of basic story structure
Genre Flip Adaptability Improves flexibility in structural approaches
Timed Writing Efficiency Enhances ability to create cohesive structures quickly
Reverse Engineering Analysis Deepens understanding of successful story structures
Character-Driven Plotting Character-plot integration Improves character development within structure

Additional Exercises for Mastering Structure:

Opening Line Challenge: Write multiple opening lines focusing on different structural approaches (e.g., action, character, setting)
Climax Construction: Practice writing climactic scenes that effectively resolve the main conflict
Resolution Variations: Write multiple endings for the same story to explore different structural possibilities
Conflict Escalation: Create a series of increasingly challenging obstacles for a character to overcome
Thematic Threading: Practice weaving a central theme throughout different structural elements of a story

Benefits of Structural Exercises:

Improved understanding of narrative flow
Enhanced ability to create engaging plots
Increased flexibility in storytelling approaches
Better integration of character development and plot structure

Tips for Effective Practice:

Set regular writing goals focused on structural elements
Analyze your own stories for structural strengths and weaknesses
Seek feedback on the structural aspects of your writing
Read widely and analyze the structures of stories you enjoy

Applying Exercise Insights to Writing:

Use insights gained from exercises to plan future stories
Experiment with different structural approaches in your writing
Develop a personal checklist for ensuring strong story structure
Regularly revisit and refine your understanding of story structure

By consistently practicing these exercises, writers can develop a strong intuition for effective story structure. This skill allows for more efficient planning and writing, as well as the ability to troubleshoot structural issues in drafts. Remember, mastering short story structure is an ongoing process that combines technical understanding with creative application. Regular practice and analysis will lead to more compelling, well-structured narratives that engage readers and effectively convey themes and emotions.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *